Mets GM Omar Minaya chose the press conference in which he announced Bernazard’s dismissal to set his sights on Rubin, the beat writer for the New York Daily News. Rubin had written a few stories on Bernazard’s more controversial actions, including an incident in Binghamton, where Bernazard reportedly removed his shirt and challenged the double-A players to a physical altercation.
The press conference began with the usual Minaya double-talk about Bernazard before it took a surprising, odd turn.
“Once the reports came out, you know, of course we had to expedite more the investigation,” Minaya said, rambling. “Early in the process, early in the process, when the reports came out, I had to kind of tell myself, ‘Wow, these things are coming out.’ And I say this because coming from Adam Rubin, okay, and Adam, you gotta understand this, Adam, for the past couple of years, has lobbied for a player development position. He has lobbied myself, he has lobbied Tony. So when these things came out I was kind of a little bit, I had to think about it. And I was a little bit, you know, somewhat, kind of, we gotta find out about this. We really have to do a thorough investigation of this.”
SNY, airing the press conference live, used an inset to show Rubin, who looked incredulous. Finally someone handed Rubin a microphone, leading to an equally strange interaction.
Rubin: “Is what you’re alleging that I tried to tear Tony down so I could take his job? Is that what you’re saying?”
Minaya: “No, no, I’m not saying that. All I’m saying was, that I know that when you wrote the reports, but I am saying, that in the past, you have, have lobbied for a job…”
Rubin: “If I were interested in working in player development somewhere in the major leagues at some point in my life, how did that impact this situation at all?”
Minaya: “I said, because, when the reports came out a lot of these things were cross… I said ‘Who's writing these reports?’ and… in the back of my mind, Adam, you have told me you have told other people in the front office that you want to work for player development in the front office.”
Rubin: “So what you’re alleging is that… the only conclusion I can draw from that is that you’re trying to allege that I tried to tear everyone down so that I could take their position. Is that what you’re saying?”
Minaya: “Adam…”
Rubin: “It seems pretty despicable to say that.”
Rubin said later he had approached Mets COO Jeff Wilpon and asked for advice about getting a job in baseball, but not specifically with the Mets.
Minaya tried to walk back his comments in a hastily-arranged press conference with Wilpon about three hours later, but he stood by his basic allegation that Rubin had campaigned for a position with the Mets while working for the Daily News.
“That was not a proper forum for me to raise those issues,” Minaya conceded.
The larger point, however, is why Minaya chose to raise those issues at all.
Either he was insinuating that Rubin fabricated all or part of the Bernazard story, or he and the Daily News chose to devote an inappropriate amount of attention on the story, because Rubin felt spurned by the Mets organization.
But Minaya never denied the Bernazard-in-Binghamton story, and Minaya is in no position to question the zeal with which the Daily News covered the story. It’s completely irrelevant to the story, and any mention of it on Minaya’s part reveals bitterness and/or paranoia.
Obviously, there is a he said, he said element to this story regarding whether Rubin lobbied the Mets for a job. Notably, Wilpon seemed to support Rubin’s statement that he was only seeking “career advice.”
But Minaya held to his claim that Rubin wanted a job with the Mets. If that is true, it definitely approaches an ethical gray area. But, again, it’s completely irrelevant to Bernazard’s firing and only serves to harm what little credibility Minaya may have had left.
Rubin said this afternoon that today’s events make it impossible for him to cover the ballclub. “I don’t know how I’m going to cover the team now,” Rubin said. “I’m absolutely floored. I asked, ‘How do you get a job in baseball?’ That's it.”
The Daily News, to their credit, is standing by Rubin. “This was a well-reported, well-researched, exclusive story,” said the News’ editor-in-chief Martin Dunn, “and it’s a shame that the Mets deemed fit to cast aspersions on our reporter instead of dealing with the issues at hand.”
“We stand by Adam 1,000 percent,” his statement said.
Today offered Minaya one more chance, an opportunity to shed some of the negativity in Flushing. Instead, today was yet another bizarre moment in a season full of bizarre moments – a season increasingly likely to cost Minaya his job.
